Burnt Orange ReportNews, Politics, and Fun From Deep in the Heart of Texas |
![]() |
February 06, 2005Give Dean A Fair ShakeBy Jim DallasThere've always been intraparty feuds, but the sky-is-falling rhetoric over Howard Dean's apparent success (here and otherwise) in winning the DNC helm is way off the charts. Howard Dean was not my first choice to be DNC Chairman; my first choice was Simon Rosenberg, because I believed he'd be the most capable leader/manager/guru. But that isn't to say I thought anyone would be patently incapable of the job, with the exception of Tim Roemer (whose unfavorables among the Democratic intelligensia probably surpass Dean's by a considerable amount). I share the anxiety of many people about Dean; like most of us here, I was in Iowa last year. If the Dean DNC will look anything like Dean for Iowa, then every quote in Garance Franke-Ruta's piece in the American Prospect will look prescient. (At the same time, from what I've heard, the New Hampshire organization was brilliant). On the other hand, Franke-Ruta, who covered the Dean campaign last year, felt compelled to back-peddle from the shrill Dean-bashing in the recent pieces by Jon Chait and Ryan Lizza. I can't agree with Greg that there's anything amiss with giving money and power to state Democratic party's. Look, the next four years could validate every fear of the Stop Dean caucus. On the other hand, it could very well shake things up. And on the third hand (I don't really have three hands, but you get the gist), it could end up meaning very little. I, for one, choose to be an optimist, or at the very least, a realist. And if I could say "let's give Bush a fair shake" (I did, by the way; he just kept acting like a jackass, so that was the end of that experiment), then I ought to be able to say the same thing about Dean. (Or, for the cynics, I am beholden to take my talking-points from the editors of the American Prospect (also here), instead of from the editors of The New Republic.) Posted by Jim Dallas at February 6, 2005 04:31 PM | TrackBackComments
I freely admit that I have never supported Dean as a good candidate for DNC chair and the reasons are lengthy. They stretch from the fact that he is so vastly unpopular, even with members of his own party, to the fact that he proved himself miserable when it came to understanding how to run a winning campaign, to his inability to manage his own staff. Not to mention the fact that I think his successful fundraising strategy was dependent on the facts that it was both an election year and he was raising money for a presidential race. Two things that are necessary to raise the kind of nickel and dime money he went after and depended on for his successful effort. Two things that will not be available to him for the majority of his tenure as DNC chair. That said, I believe the party is lacking unity and I don’t believe at this point a shouting match about why Dean is not the best candidate for the job will benefit anyone. As they say, “It’s all over but the crying”. For those of us who supported who we believed to be stronger candidates for chair, it’s time to wipe our cheeks, take a couple of deep breaths, count to ten if necessary and start looking to the future. I am in favor of supporting Dean with my loyalty, but not necessarily with my money. I believe as Democrats in Texas and in other red states it is time for us to really start working on the problems we may have within our state parties. It’s time to look to our state parties for leadership and doing what it takes to win back congressional and senate seats. Remember, national political control is won one state at a time. I know it’s an old story by now, but the fact is the national party has been raising money in Texas, I believe Texas ranks #3 when it comes to national contributions from a state. It is also an old but true story, that Texas has been largely ignored by the national party, and to be honest I don’t think Dean will change this. Before I send them money I need to know what the DNC’s strategy will be in our state. Whatever it is, with out a great deal of consulting I don’t believe it will be a winning one, I simply do not believe Dean knows what it takes to win in the red. But I believe many of us in Texas do. That’s why I advocate spending our money in our own state, concentrating on getting Democrats elected at home both to state and national office. It is time we separate ourselves from a dependency on the national party in U.S. house and Senate races. I think it can be done, in fact, I think after some of the anger and dissatisfaction among moderate voters regarding redistricting, we may be on the cusp of a golden opportunity in this state to start swinging back blue. Democratic Suicide. Thats what they are calling the now certain victory of Howard Dean for the DNC chairmanship. How absurd. Anyone whose fingers are still numb from Dean's loss in Iowa will tell you how quickly perceptions can change. Howard Dean will continue to manage the party's funds wisely and bring much needed investments to our state organizations. Come 2008 we will run a 50 state campaign. Dean is rhetorically gifted but I believe he will forgo the talk show circuit after his victory and immediately go to work. Howard Dean was a lot of things before he was a failed presidential candidate. Those who see him as a caricature, a screaming maniac, a loony; are going to be surprised. Their perceptions will be turned upside down when he turns out to be a successful and component chair. Posted by: Jordan Kramer at February 8, 2005 09:16 PMI certainly hope Dean does turn out to be a competent chair. I however am not looking for mere competence. I as well as other Democrats particularly in the state of Texas better be looking for something pretty G.D. remarkable. I also am no fool, I recognize Dean is more than the screaming lunatic the press portrayed during the primaries, and however, I remain unimpressed. I am aware of his fundraising skills during, I repeat, an election year, I am aware of not only the outcome of his primary race but the races he supported, I am mostly aware of how his campaign was managed, again, I remain unimpressed. I am not declaring a Dean win Democratic suicide. I am however advocating for Texas and other states in similar situations to move forward and take charge of their/our own states politics. We have the money, we have the know how. It's time we utilize it. Again, not to be the voice of discord, but well then again maybe I am. I simply do not know how Dean is going to prove helpful in a state like Texas where he's less popular than the Dixie Chicks. (well, on the whole, some of us still love you chicks.) Post a comment
|
|